Beyond the Cusp

March 29, 2013

The Ignored Reason There is no Palestinian State Already

Filed under: 1949 Armistice Line,1967 Borders,1967 War,Abu Mazzen,Act of War,Administration,al-Qaeda in Gaza,Amalekites,Anti-Israel,Anti-Semitism,Anti-Zionist,Arab League,Arab World,Arabist,Balfour Declaration,Ben Gurion,Blood Libel,Borders,Boycott,Britain,British Mandate,Building Freeze,Building Freeze,Cabinet,Caliphate,Cave of the Patriarchs,Checkpoints,Churchill White Paper,Civilization,Coalition,Condemning Israel,Consequences,Defend Country,Defend Israel,Dictator,Disengagement,Divestment,Economic Growth,Egypt,Elections,Employment,Enlightenment,Equal Opportunity,Europe,European Governments,Executive Order,Fatah,Gamal Abdel Nasser,Gaza,Government,Green Line,Halal,Hamas,Hate,History,IDF,Intifada,Iraq,Islam,Islamic Jihad,Islamist,Israel,Israeli Capital City,Jerusalem,Jewish Heritage,Jewish Home,Jewish Leadership,Jewish State,Jewish Temple,Jews,Jobs,Jordan,Jordan River,Jordan Valley,Judea,Judean Hills,Kotel,Land for Peace,Mahmoud Abbas,Media,Middle East,Ministership,Muslim Brotherhood,Muslim World,Myth,Naqba,Nationalist,Negev Desert,Old City,One State Solution,Oslo Accords,Palestinian,Palestinian Authority,Palestinian Legislative Committee,Palestinian Security Force,Parliament,Parliamentary Government,Partition Plan,Peace Process,Peel Commission,PLO,Politics,Pre-Conditions,President for Life,Prime Minister,Prime Minister,Prisoner Release,Promised Land,Protect Citizenry,Recognize Israel,Refugee Camp,Refugees,Response to Terrorism,Right of Return,Samaria,San Remo Conference,Separation Barrier,Settlements,Sharia Law,Shechem,Statehood,Submission,Syria,Temple Mount,Temple Mount,Terror,Theocracy,Third Intifada,United Nations,United States,Voting,War,Western Wall,White Papers,Yasser Arafat — qwertster @ 4:32 AM
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Ask any European leader or politician and the odds are you will hear that the reason there is no Palestinian State is due to Israeli refusals to make peace and the Israeli settlements. They will speak of how the Palestinians are thirsting for peace and crave their own State and have made generous offers if only Israel would compromise. They will never mention the refusals over the decades by the Arab League, Yasser Arafat, and Mahmoud Abbas to every offer beginning with the initial offer from the United Nations to found the Palestinian State on the more select and prime farming lands between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea leaving only a thin strip of land along the Mediterranean Sea, another along the northwest at the bottom of the Golan Heights and over half of the land being the southern lands of the Negev Dessert. The Zionists accepted this hardly equal or fair division while the Arab League refused to allow this partition as it still allowed the Jews to rule themselves and demanded that all the land be relegated to Arab rule and they would allow the Jews to remain as long as they behaved like good Dhimmis. The United Nations and the world simply left the offer to stand in hopes that the Arab League would accept the plan, but come the middle of May, 1948, Israel declared their nationhood and seven Arab nations’ armies declared a war of annihilation against the Nascent Jewish State of Israel. Miraculously, the small newly found State of Israel managed to survive and even gain lands by pushing the combined Arab armies back taking the western half of Jerusalem within hours of the declared ceasefire taking hold. At this point there was no Israeli presence in the lands of Gaza, Judea, or Samaria with Egypt retaining control of Gaza and Jordan retaining control over Judea and Samaria which they refused to call by their historic names substituting the less descriptive and un-Jewish name of West Bank. Jordan even attempted to annex the lands they called the West Bank and made the Arabs living within Jordanian citizens. This seemed natural as the Arabs living in the area mostly had relatives either in Jordan or in either Syria or Iraq as most had arrived over the past two generations as the economy offered better employment. Jordan’s annexation of the West Bank was not recognized not even by the other Arab nations or the Arab League and was recognized solely by Great Britain and Pakistan in the entire world. Jordan also forced the Jewish residents within their areas of control to leave their property behind and expelled them into Israel. Meanwhile, Israeli Prime Minister Ben-Gurion offered for the Arabs living within Israel to remain and join in building a future. Despite this invitation many Arabs fled into neighboring Jordan, Egypt or Syria where they eventually ended up placed in camps, denied citizenship largely due to their not joining in the war against Israel; causing them to be seen as less loyal.

During the next decade over three-quarters of a million Jews were stripped of their wealth, lands, businesses and were deported from the majority of the countries of the Arab League with the majority finding a new home and a place to restart their lives in Israel while some went to Europe, the United States and other destinations. The Jews who were ejected from their homes often with only the clothes on their backs or a suitcase or two were welcomed in Israel and were granted citizenship and full rights and today they and their descendants make up approximately half of the Israeli population. This makes the claim by many Palestinian and Arab spokespersons that Israelis should be returned to the lands from whence they came in Europe and the United States ignores that half of the Israelis lived originally in the Arab world. One must wonder if these countries would open their arms and accept the descendants of the Jews they ejected. Somehow I just cannot see that ever happening.

Since 1948 Israel has been attacked by her Arab neighbors a number of times. Resulting from the first conflict where France, Great Britain and Israel declared war of Egypt after Gamal Abdel Nasser nationalized the Suez Canal and refused to allow European shipping to pass through the canal, Israel took possession of the entire Sinai Peninsula during this conflict but returned every inch of the lands to Egypt as part of the peace treaty that also saw the reopening of the Suez Canal to international shipping. United Nations peacekeepers were also stationed in the Sinai Peninsula to prevent another conflict from erupting. In late May, 1967, Egypt’s Gamal Abdel Nasser ordered the peacekeepers removed from the Sinai Peninsula, massed troops on the Israeli southern border, closed the Straights of Tiran and massed Syrian troops on the Israeli northern border threatening to annihilate the Jewish State. The closing of the Straights of Tiran was an internationally recognized casus belli of war. Israel responded to this declaration and defeated both armies driving almost to the outskirts of Damascus and taking the entire Sinai Peninsula once again. Close to the beginning of the war upon hearing of great Arab victories that Egyptian and Syrian radio and television broadcast they were executing against the Israelis, Jordan declared war in the hopes on taking their part in the glorious victory. The Israelis pleaded for Jordan not to enter the conflict warning them that the broadcasts were untrue and were simply propaganda. Jordan did not trust the Israelis believing they were simply frightened of another Arab army entering the war which would definitely contribute to the end of the Jewish state. The results of the Six Day War are well known and by the end of the conflict, in response to the United Nations and World pressures, Israel halted their advances also now having driven the Jordanians back east of the Jordan River liberating occupied Judea and Samaria (one must recall that Jordan illegally occupied the so-called West Bank which was originally believed to be part of Israel). During Yom Kippur of October, 1973 Egypt and Syria once again attacked Israel hoping to reclaim the lands lost in 1967 and destroy the Jewish State. After initial gains the war ended with Israel retaining all of the Sinai Peninsula and having crossed the Suez Canal and approaching Cairo as well as approaching Damascus in Syria. When hostilities ended, Israel agreed to return to the borders which had existed since the 1967 conflict returning lands to both Egypt and Syria lands gained during the closing days of the conflict. Eventually Israel and Egypt made peace (for those who claim Israel must return some of the lands they gained in the 1967 war remember the following) with Israel returning all of the Sinai Peninsula once again, an expanse of land greatly larger than all of Israel. Egypt refused any claim to Gaza which was relented to Israeli sovereignty. Further on in time Jordan and Israel also reached a peace accord in which Jordan surrendered the previously Jordanian occupied lands to Israel liberating the lands and allowing many Jewish families to reclaim their lands and homes they had left when Jordan forcibly removed them in 1948.

Somewhere the world acquiesced to the invention of peoples whom had never existed in all of history and was admitted by even Yasser Arafat they were necessarily invented in order to have a political wedge with which to remove the Jews from Arab sovereign lands, namely Israel. This twist of history beyond recognition of any historic accounts dated previous to 1920 has gained great recognition and a life all its own in Europe as well as throughout the Arab and Muslim lands. Historically, before 1948 the use of the title Palestinian had several different forms, Palestinian Arab was used to define Arabs living within the British Mandate, Palestinian Jews or simple using Palestinian alone was used to refer to the Jews living within the British Mandate. In 1922 the nation of Transjordan, later renamed simply Jordan, was founded with the issue of the Churchill White Paper where Transjordan was granted for rule by the Hashemite family repaying them for their assistance against the Ottomans in World War I and they were to rule over a Palestinian State. This was the British reaction in response to Arab insistence for a country of their own within the British Mandate. The Arab demands implied they should have their country formed over all of the British Mandate but the British still had their obligation stemming from the Balfour Declaration, the Peel Commission, Article 80 of the United Nations Charter and numerous other treaties and agreements to found a Jewish homeland. The White Paper which established the Palestinian Arab State of Transjordan also guaranteed that the lands west of the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea would remain never to be divided and remain as whole and in its entirety as the Jewish Homeland. This accord was also ratified by motions and legislations in the League of Nations, the United States and several European nations. That is the history; the future is far less resolute and will likely be a thorn as intended by Yasser Arafat and those who initiated the demand for another Arab nation in place of the only Jewish nation on Earth. This desire to replace Israel with one or two new Palestinian Arab states, whichever becomes necessary by events to come, is understood as the inevitable aim of the Arab world but is never spoken of as to admit to knowing this would reveal all the duplicities, animosities, hatreds, and lies which are the realities of the negotiations the world calls the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process, originally the Arab-Israeli Peace Process but renamed in order to mask the ultimate aim of the destruction of Israel.

Beyond the Cusp

April 10, 2012

Abbas and PLO Facing Difficulties on Three Fronts

Much is made in the news about the constant maneuvering between Mahmoud Abbas representing the Palestinian Authority with Hamas in their political and Gaza leaderships attempting to find sufficient common ground for agreement. The problem is each side insists that they retain authority over their respective areas of influence while attempting to gain inroads on the other side’s areas of control. At stake is who gains controlling leadership not only of the Palestinian Authority but also of the PLO. The latest round of dances had agreements reached between Abbas and the political leadership in Qatar before everything fell apart when the Gaza leadership of Hamas made additional demands when meeting for final signing of the agreements with Mahmoud Abbas and the other leadership from the PLO. The signing fell shattered as the two sides could not harmonize away their differences.

On the other well recognized front there is the moribund Palestinian-Israeli peace process. Mahmoud Abbas keeps setting an ever more impossible series of precondition for Israel to agree on before he will join negotiations that he claims really are being arranged with no preconditions. By this standard Mahmoud Abbas refuses to recognize the Israeli right to exist as a Jewish democratic country or any other items as the negotiations have been set by the Quartet to be free of preconditions. When challenged on how he can claim to not accept any Israeli requests while demanding Israel accept the 1967 borders, suspend all building in the disputed areas, the release of all Palestinian Arab terror and political prisoners from Israeli detention, and other demands that seem to change with the seasons, Abbas simply states that these are not preconditions, they are merely benchmarks which Israel is required to meet before he will agree to hold negotiations on even more demands.

But it may not be either of these challenges that will bring to an end the entire house of cards that is Mahmoud Abass’s little fiefdom. Just west of the Jordan River a storm is brewing just under the radar of the news cycles. With the loud clashes which continue next door in Syria gaining all the headlines and attention, the slowly building troubles for the continued rule of King Hussein in Jordan are hardly noticed. The rough relations between the Hashemite ruler and his mainly Palestinian Arab population has been simmering ever since their uprising led by Yasser Arafat in September 1970, called Black September, after which Yasser Arafat continued on to completely disrupt Lebanon before being exiled to Tunisia. Where the Palestinian Arab discontent being an accepted norm, one might wonder what has changed that makes the current unrest so ominous. The once loyal Bedouin Tribes are also joining in the demonstrations against King Hussein and the slow to nonexistent reforms in governance which have been promised since before the beginning of the Arab Spring of last year and have slowly been escalating since the changes started to sweep the Arab world. Since King Hussein has depended upon his Bedouin manned Army to enforce order and continue his rule, the fact that this arrangement may be coming upon rough times poses a serious challenge to his continued rule. The one comfort the world can take from this particular roiling pot of troubles is that King Hussein is far more likely to abdicate and take up residence in England or some other location in the West rather than take the route of open confrontation and releasing the Jordanian Army upon his subjects. King Hussein actually cares about his people despite his reluctance and seeming inability to give up any of his power over all parts of the country’s governance.

Should Jordan throw off the reign of King Hussein, it would quickly take on the persona which was the original intended reason for the founding of Transjordan, the predecessor to modern day Jordan, of being the Palestinian Arab State. This was the precondition for the founding of Transjordan which was sold to the League of Nations when it was carved out of the British Mandate Lands which had originally been set aside to serve as a homeland for Jews. The British caved to Arab insistence and rejection of such a sizable, actually any, amount of land being given to non-Arabs, and especially to the Jews. It was decided to take the 78% of the British Mandate east of the Jordan River for the Palestinian Arab country leaving the remainder west of the Jordan River for the Jewish state. Should Jordan be released from Hashemite rule and King Hussein and his Queen abdicate their throne, Jordan will once again be a Palestinian Arab land as over three quarters of the population consists of Palestinian Arabs who had migrated to the area from Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and other Arab countries beginning in the middle and late nineteenth century and continuing through the first half of the twentieth century. With Jordan returning to its Palestinian Arab roots it will also become the obvious solution to the Palestinian-Israeli problems. Even should some parts of Judea and Samaria be surrendered from Israeli control, they could be released conditionally on they be ruled by Jordan and the entire Palestinian Authority and the PLO be incorporated into Jordan thus joining the two Palestinian areas into one country rather than having two countries for the same basic population which have identical origins.

The fact that Mahmoud Abbas can look in any direction and see threats to his hold on power and importance, it is no wonder he appears to be thrashing and desperate to force issues to a head before any of those external threats finish closing in and replacing him. Imminent obsolescence often brings out the worst in people and Mahmoud Abbas has had an ever diminishing appearance of acceptable traits to begin with. Life will likely be a healthier and more pleasant once we no longer are berated with Mahmoud Abbas and his ranting and whining about how the world has dealt he and his people a raw deal. Though claiming to be of all Palestinian Arab upbringing, his history is quite interesting and reveals that though Mahmoud Abbas was born in Safed in the Galilee, he and his family fled to Syria during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War where he lived and subsequently graduated from the University of Damascus before going to Egypt where he studied law then later entered graduate studies at the Patrice Lumumba University in Moscow. He is barely more of a true Palestinian Arab than the Egyptian Yasser Arafat. How nice it will be to finally force Abbas to face the election he has gone to great lengths to avoid through innumerable election postponements and have him sent back to obscurity when his leadership is rightfully rejected by the entirety of the Palestinian Arab peoples.

Beyond the Cusp

« Previous Page

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: